CCR rebreathers differences and what to look for

04/21/2025

Considering an electronic CCR (eCCR) rebreather for your next diving adventure? Choosing the right eCCR isn't just about investing in advanced equipment; it's about maximizing safety, performance, and long-term value. This guide is specifically crafted for technically-minded divers exploring eCCR options, seeking clarity on critical differences between top models like the Divesoft Liberty and its competitors. Dive into the specifics and discover exactly what makes an eCCR system superior.

Why Choose eCCR Over mCCR?

Automation and Safety

Modern diving technology has dramatically enhanced diver safety through electronic control systems. eCCR systems automatically maintain optimal breathing mixtures, allowing divers to focus on situational awareness and reducing the chance of human error.

Limitations of Manual Systems

Manual CCRs (mCCR), while offering precise control, require constant attention—especially during ascent when oxygen management becomes critical. In emergency situations, task-overload can easily distract divers, increasing the risk of dangerous hypoxia. mCCR scheme

Standard eCCR Systems

Standard eCCRs reduce diver workload by automating oxygen injection based on real-time sensor readings. This allows divers to focus on navigation, buoyancy, and situational awareness. However, many commercially available eCCR models do not offer robust backup systems. In the event of an electronic failure—such as a controller or sensor malfunction—there is often no secondary system to seamlessly take over. This lack of redundancy can place divers at risk, especially during deep or extended dives where bailout options are limited. eCCR scheme

Redundancy in Modern eCCRs

Concerns over electronic failures once favored mCCR systems. However, today’s eCCRs, including the Liberty, incorporate robust redundancy, making them highly reliable even in the rare case of individual system component failure. Fault tolerant Liberty eCCR scheme

Hybrid CCRs

Hybrid systems (hCCR) combine manual and electronic components. While they use the same constant flow orifice (jet) as mCCR—thus being depth-limited like mCCR—they have an advantage in that the electronics monitor the oxygen partial pressure. However, unlike eCCR systems, these electronics are usually not redundant.

Rebreather comparison chart

➡️ Read: 5 Basic Principles of Rebreather and One Extra and learn more about all rebreather types.

What Sets Divesoft Liberty Apart?

Complete System Redundancy

Reliable Backup Electronics

Unlike many other CCRs, the Liberty features fully redundant electronics. Any single electronic component failure is automatically backed up, ensuring uninterrupted and safe operation.

Unique Modular Design

Versatile Configuration Options

Quick transitions between backmount and sidemount configurations enhance versatility for technical and recreational divers alike.

Advanced Safety Features

Diagnostics and Sensor Redundancy

Redundant electronics and sensor systems provide unmatched safety and clear, real-time diagnostics.

Global Support Network

Liberty Divers Club & Social Media Groups

An extensive international service network ensures reliable support worldwide. And importantly: diving is a community experience.

Not having anybody to share your experience with can hinder your development. It's essential to have a network of fellow divers using the same system.

CCR Liberty community

Join the Liberty Divers Club or connect through groups on social media to find dive buddies, share knowledge, and keep progressing together.

Superior Electronics

Intuitive Interface and Long Battery Life

User-friendly interfaces and excellent battery efficiency make the Liberty ideal for long, demanding dives.

Optimal Breathing Comfort

Effortless Breathing in All Positions

The Liberty ensures consistently effortless breathing in all diving positions, improving comfort, reducing fatigue, and enhancing diver performance.

Common Buyer Mistakes to Avoid

Prioritizing Cost Over Value

Opting for a lower-cost system might seem like a smart move upfront, but in the long term, it can compromise safety and performance. Cheaper systems often cut corners—whether it's through limited sensor redundancy, lack of reliable electronics, or offering only manual (mCCR) operation. As covered earlier, mCCR systems demand high attention and carry increased risks in high-stress environments.

Choosing a reliable, well-supported eCCR like the Liberty helps ensure you're investing in a system that can grow with you and perform consistently in all conditions.

Overlooking Serviceability

Selecting an eCCR without accessible local service options can become costly and inconvenient.

Rebreather service

➡️ Find your nearest service technician: Locate support near you

Underestimating Training Needs

eCCRs require specialized training.

We offer a comprehensive learning path to help you succeed.
➡️ Find your nearest instructor or dealer: Locate instructor near you
➡️ Read: 7 Steps to Becoming a Rebreather Diver and learn about certifications and course offerings.

Take the Next Step with Confidence

The right eCCR rebreather will transform your diving experience. With clear insights on essential features and common pitfalls, you're prepared to choose confidently. If safety, versatility, and global support matter to you, the Divesoft Liberty clearly stands out.

Ready to explore further? Schedule your demo dive today and experience the Liberty difference firsthand!

Author: Jakub Šimánek

Divesoft.app

Plan your decompression, gasses, utilize checklists, check your logs + more.

All for Free.